If you haven't read my first post about this film, you can find it here. This post will build on some of the ideas already outlined in that post. Also, heavy spoilers again, so if you have not watched the film, go watch it, then come back to read this.
Clark frees Mary's right hand, but the monster enters the room before he can finish releasing her. Mary unties her bindings herself with her right hand. I believe this is the reason we see her hands in that position as a still life.
The Night I was Kicked out of My Own House
This is not original to me, but this theory is one I haven't heard mentioned by many people. I suspect that Clark was physically abusive to his wife, Barbara, on that night he was kicked out. Here are my primary reasons.
First, I don't think Clark would have left of his own accord. I suspect law enforcement would have had to get involved. If you think about what could have caused law enforcement to remove the person whose name is on the house, I think they would have to be at fault and a threat to the other party.
The red-headed still life (the woman figure in the backrooms scene where Clark has Mary tied up), if she is truly a "remembered version of Barbara" she reacts in terror and fleas the backrooms version of Clark (Pirate Clark). This makes sense if her remembered version was terrified of the violent drunk Clark that is personified in Pirate Clark. When he enters the room, that Barbara still life reacts based on her remembered experience.
In my previous post, I also mentioned the fact that the still life entities in the dinner room scene have different distortions. The man in the striped shirt has a vertical distortion with multiple sets of eyes. The woman in red's facial distortion is horizontal with noses and distorted mouth. I speculated that maybe this was due to Clark's memory of her always shaking her head "no", but I now suspect that it could be that her face is distorted that way because Clark hit her, so he saw her face turn to the side when he struck her face.
Physical abuse would also explain the fact that Clark was in therapy. Clark never seemed truly invested in therapy and I don't think a man with Clark's mentality would volunteer to start therapy. He is convinced his problems are other people's fault, not caused by his failures. A judge could have given Clark that option as a means of staying out of jail.
This is speculation, but it makes sense to me.
Mary's Still Life
Mary's still life figure that is featured in the very last scene in the film is depicting two important moments. I think most people pick up on the obvious one, that she's in a remembered version of the interrogation room where she is interviewed by Phil. However, I believe the position of her hands is a memory reflection of the moment she is frantically untying her left hand that remained bound while Clark was greeting (and being killed by) Pirate Clark in the dinner scene.
More than One Allegory
Many people have commented about this movie being an allegory for the way we deal with trauma and negative emotions. Mary and Clark both struggled in these areas. Mary survives by putting a physical token of her trauma to good use. Clark's embodied emotional nightmare literally destroys him when he decides he can embrace his penchant for pushing people away and hurting them. "It's okay. We don't have to change!"
I believe I also mentioned how the backrooms themselves are a metaphor for our own memories more generally and how they are very imperfect, that we recall things incorrectly and the more times we remember events, the worse our recall is.
But knowing a little about the background of the storyline and lore of the backrooms, I think Kane Parsons is setting the stage for a larger allegory related to the tech industry, represented in Backrooms by the ASYNC company.
ASYNC either creates or discovers the backrooms. They have plans to monetize their creation/discovery. That's all fine. However, it quickly becomes clear that their creation isn't marketable because it's not safe. The creators become obsessed with their own creation. They become aware that outside people and children are being harmed and killed by their creation (the initial creation event causes an earthquake that kills dozens of people). Their own staff are being killed in the backrooms. But instead of cutting their losses and shutting it down, ASYNC doubles down, they get a government grant. They work to keep the damage they have done hidden.
This isn't apparent in the film alone, and I could be mistaken about the direction Parsons will take as the series progresses, but considering the fact that social media companies have developed algorithms that feed on the negative emotions we have; fear, hate, rage. These algorithms have driven false information to be passed around. They have caused divisions. They keep people engaged in the applications for unhealthy amounts of time. They cause depression, anxiety, and have been linked to suicides. AI has told people bad information that has led to loss of money, depression, AI agents have given people instructions on how to end their lives, and some agents have committed felonies. They are also contributing to confusion and anger on the internet through social media outlets with bogus images, videos, and false information and propaganda.
ASYNC either creates or discovers the backrooms. They have plans to monetize their creation/discovery. That's all fine. However, it quickly becomes clear that their creation isn't marketable because it's not safe. The creators become obsessed with their own creation. They become aware that outside people and children are being harmed and killed by their creation (the initial creation event causes an earthquake that kills dozens of people). Their own staff are being killed in the backrooms. But instead of cutting their losses and shutting it down, ASYNC doubles down, they get a government grant. They work to keep the damage they have done hidden.
This isn't apparent in the film alone, and I could be mistaken about the direction Parsons will take as the series progresses, but considering the fact that social media companies have developed algorithms that feed on the negative emotions we have; fear, hate, rage. These algorithms have driven false information to be passed around. They have caused divisions. They keep people engaged in the applications for unhealthy amounts of time. They cause depression, anxiety, and have been linked to suicides. AI has told people bad information that has led to loss of money, depression, AI agents have given people instructions on how to end their lives, and some agents have committed felonies. They are also contributing to confusion and anger on the internet through social media outlets with bogus images, videos, and false information and propaganda.
These companies have known this based on their own research and they have attempted to bury this information and keep it from the public so they can continue to turn people's data and attention into massive profits.
Again, this isn't a theme that is in the foreground in the movie, but I anticipate it's coming with future installments. Parsons has indicated in interviews that the true central character of the series is Ivan Beck, who is the inventor and founder of the backrooms. As the ASYNC company's prominence is moved into the foreground of Parsons' narrative, I think this parallel will become clear. We'll see.
Alice in Wonderland themes
Many people have pointed out a similarity with Alice in Wonderland with regard to the tiny door through which Clark escapes from the throne room in his first foray into the backrooms. Alice also finds herself in strange corridors with many doors, which obviously smacks of the backrooms.
I have not heard many people point out that the dinner scene also has some similarities (and interesting contrasts) with the Mad Hatter's tea party.
It's not so on the nose, but Clark is clearly "mad" in that scene and Alice/Mary is surrounded by very strange characters. The Mad Hatter's tea party has three guests and Clark has three guests.
There are probably a greater number of dissimilarities because Mary's presence at Clark's dinner, isn't optional. Alice wants to join the tea party but she is given a hard time about it because she wasn't technically invited. Mary is offered food she doesn't want to eat. Alice sees food she wants, but it isn't offered. The Mad Hatter comments about Alice needing a haircut at one point. Clark cuts the still life of Barbara's hair off her head (scalping her) and puts it on Mary's head. The Mad Hatter's guests are chatty and Clark's guests are all silent observers (at least until the monster arrives). Clark forces Mary to go through the roll play exercise he did with her in therapy. Alice is asked to perform in other ways, by answering riddles and telling stories. The contrasts are possibly just as interesting as the similarities.
But both Alice and Mary reach a point of agitation with their hosts.
"It's the stupidest tea party I ever was at in all my life!"
But both Alice and Mary reach a point of agitation with their hosts.
"It's the stupidest tea party I ever was at in all my life!"
The stakes were considerably lower for Alice. Haha.
Ah! This just occurred to me. Maybe Pirate Clark is the Alice in Wonderland who crashes the party uninvited! Hahaha. That changes things. Imagine getting a second installment of the backrooms franchise from the perspective of Pirate Clark where he's the victim (just like Clark thinks he's always the victim).
I think this is all I have for now. Please share your thoughts and theories. Do I have anything completely wrong? Let me know.
Cheers,
Gavagai




Comments
Post a Comment